A Reluctant Book Recommendation

lifeWhen a meteor hits the moon and knocks it closer in orbit to the earth, nothing will ever be the same.

Worldwide tidal waves.


Volcanic eruptions.

And that’s just the beginning.

So is the premise for a young adult novel I just finished reading. No apocalyptic-nut can resist a book that has that as its description. Maybe it was because of The Hunger Games that made me feel like I’m not too old to be reading this teen book. Or maybe I just like really, really good stories about the end of the world. Either way, Life As We Knew It by Susan Beth Pfeffer didn’t disappoint.

To be sure, it disappointed in a few ways, but not the way I expected. I’ll get to that in a minute. The story flowed smoothly, the characters were likable and believable, and it was one of those fictional books that got into my head – like, really got in there. To the point where I was nervous about the refrigerator being left open for too long the other night because of how important it was to keep our food rations fresh.

Written in the style of Anne Frank, the book felt real, and intense, and sometimes scary. Yes, it had me planning ahead for what would happen if the moon did get knocked closer to the earth. Good news is, according to this book, my wife and I will be safe in Kentucky. You Floridians and Californians will mostly be wiped out. Good bye New England and parts of India. Gone.

But the reason I’m reluctant to recommend this book to teens is because of the unnecessary political and religious agenda that the author spews out onto its pages, soiling this otherwise flawless book.

Pfeffer spends a good deal of the first part of the book bashing President Bush, making one of the main characters, a mother, yell at him whenever he’s on the TV calling him an idiot and saying she hates him. What else are the mother’s kids to do but laugh and agree? To be fair, I wouldn’t think it would be necessary for an author to pull the same stunt against Obama or Clinton or Carter. I just hate to see such outright political propaganda spelled out so clearly in a teen fiction book.

(This book was selected for the ALA Best Book for Young Adults amongst many other prestigious honors, by the way.)

But praise be to Pfeffer, her writing style and suspenseful plot was just enough to keep me from throwing the book away. It has a few bad words throughout, but nothing overt or out of proper context. Though it doesn’t feature Twilight-type sex-praising, it does feature teens making out a few times.

But the saddest part about the book for me was the author’s apparent bump-ins with Christians in her life. It reads clearly that she has a deep disdain for Christians and our beliefs. Judging by the book, I feel like she’s only met the type of Christians who’s only answer to every terrible crisis in life is to pray about it and be happy – always happy. The Christians featured in her book are shallow and naive, on purpose, I’m sure.

One Christian teenager the author portrays in the book starves herself because she feels it is God’s will for her life. If only Pfeffer knew that the Bible does not condone such awful behavior and any Christian who would do that would be/ought to be condemned by the church. A reverend comes across as a holier-than-thou jerk, who turns out to be hoarding his congregation’s food during the famine. His answer to everyone’s plea was always, “I’ll pray for you.” Luther would have had a hay day with this guy.

In fact, her “Christians” portray the exact people Jesus spent much of His ministry rebuking. At least this book can be an eye-opener for some of us as to how the world may perceive us, and may we change our ways.

I never want to avoid recommending a book because of any author’s beliefs, just like I would hate it if people refused to read my book because of my beliefs. But I do want to make readers aware of them, and help people to read (and write) regardless of their personal agendas. Art is art, and this book is a work of beauty, at least in a secular sense.

I hear there are two others in the series, and I’ll be grabbing them soon, and I’m sure I’ll be reveling every page – well, most of them, anyway.

Purchase it here on Amazon.

Follow what else I’m reading on Goodreads.

[Image Credit]


About Andrew Toy
I'm in the beginning stages of starting my own publishing company that's unlike anything you've ever heard of in the industry. The direction of AdoptingJames is taking a 90-degree turn and will be more writing/publishing-focused. Stay tuned for huge updates and exciting news!

7 Responses to A Reluctant Book Recommendation

  1. markharwoodwriter says:

    Fantastic review, thanks!

  2. Thanks for an honest review… My thinking would be pretty much in line with you, I think. Expository writing is the forum for explaining your beliefs and your views (e.g., biographies, memoirs, political books, religious content, essays, et al). Authors, in my opinion, take away from their fictional work when they espouse their personal prejudices…much like movie stars and public entertainers using their celebrity to promote a cause. They certainly have the right to express those views publically but they run the risk of alienating their fan bases — and, surely, most of them could care less.

    I’ve made the same mistake in books I’ve written, allowing my protagonist to go a little too far with personal beliefs. In my fictional memoir and in the non-fictional sketch of my life, I do lay bare my feelings… In that venue people can think of me what they will.

    Sorry, this is not about me, but about your review… A review I found entertaining and informative. Thank you for sharing it. Though it is a ‘skeptical recommendation’ of her book, Ms Pfeffer should be pleased overall, I should think.

    My best wishes.

  3. I have this book, its good. But you’re right. I’m generally not a fan of author’s using their fictional work to force their beliefs – especially with young teens. Although a lot of the time it’s just a side effect of having those beliefs, and not necessarily a conscious effort. Either way I enjoyed this book…moreso than Twilight 😀

  4. I loved the idea for this book! I didn’t know what to expect when I started reading it (I’m a pretty firm believer in not reading the back cover), so I was surprised to find out that the moon actually moved!

  5. Pingback: Dreadful Reading « adoptingjames

  6. Great book review. About the Christians..well, I’d be similarly annoyed if atheists were portrayed in a stereotypical way. And yet, I have to give limited credence to the ‘the bible doesn’t say that..’ argument that many liberal, well meaning Christians use against fundamentalists. The bible says a lot of things, some we’d now judge as ‘good’ and with it, others that we’d judge as outdated, violent and bigoted – as a Christian, aren’t you bound to take all of it as written, not pick the bits that go well with modern life?

  7. Pingback: Christmas Wish List Part 4 | adoptingjames

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: